The Lean Startup Mafia — How a Small Group Still Shapes a Global Startup Doctrine
In the early 2010s a new mantra took over the startup world: “Build–Measure–Learn.”
It came from The Lean Startup by Eric Ries, and it quickly evolved from a book into a global doctrine — one that universities, accelerators, governments, corporates, and investors adopted without questioning the underlying assumptions.
Over time, critics started using a tongue-in-cheek term for the ecosystem around it:
“The Lean Startup Mafia.”
Not because it is criminal — but because a small, tightly connected circle of U.S. authors, investors, and founders shaped and still shape a single dominant way of thinking about innovation. And everyone else was expected to follow.
What Is the Lean Startup Mafia?
The term refers to the network of influencers who created, promoted, and commercialized the Lean Startup methodology. This network often overlaps with the PayPal Mafia, Silicon Valley VCs, and the U.S. startup elite.
Their influence comes from three things:
- Publishing and thought leadership
- Accelerator and VC networks
- Corporate consulting and government programs
Together, they still set the rules for what “startup innovation” and innovation in general should look like — from Silicon Valley to Europe, Asia, and inside large corporates and universities and business schools and on LinkedIn.
The Core Figures Behind the Lean Startup Mafia
1. Eric Ries — The Architect
- Author of The Lean Startup
- Founder of the “Lean Startup Co.”
- Close ties to Silicon Valley VC networks including people in The PayPal Maffia
- Turned lean into a consulting and certification business
2. Steve Blank — The Foundation Layer
- Ries’ mentor
- Author of The Four Steps to the Epiphany
- Created Customer Development, the backbone of Lean Startup
- Strong ties to U.S. defense innovation and VC programs
3. Ash Maurya — The Codifier
- Creator of the Lean Canvas
- Popular in corporate innovation programs
- Extended Lean Startup into tools, templates, and courses
4. Silicon Valley VCs Behind the Scenes
Not always in the spotlight but extremely influential:
- Peter Thiel (Founders Fund)
- Marc Andreessen (a16z)
- Reid Hoffman (Greylock)
- Dave McClure (500 Startups)
They promoted and still promote The Lean Startup as the model that best fits their interests:
start fast, take VC money early, scale, exit.
5. Corporate and Government Partners
Lean Startup became a global industry because it was adopted by:
- accelerators
- corporate innovation labs
- ministries of economic affairs
- universities
- defense innovation programs (especially in the U.S.)
This institutionalization is what transformed a method into a doctrine.
Why Critics Call It a “Mafia”
Not because it is illegal, but because the system works like a closed power network:
1. One ideology dominates all others
Build–Measure–Learn became the “only correct” way to innovate.
Alternative models — values-driven innovation, survival entrepreneurship, real-world battlefield innovation (Ukraine), or low-cost bootstrapping — were ignored.
2. It creates dependency
Lean Startup encourages:
- early VC funding
- external accelerators
- long validation cycles
- dependency on mentors, coaches, and corporate programs
This is the opposite of independence-focused models like in Ukraine.
3. It exports a U.S.-centric view of innovation
Lean Startup assumes:
- venture capital is the goal
- fast scaling is the metric
- failure is acceptable
- customers behave like U.S. tech consumers
This is often incompatible with European, African, Asian, or wartime environments where survival and independence matter more than “hypergrowth.”
4. It benefits the same small group and people in their network financially
Books, courses, speaking tours, accelerators, certifications —
the revenue flows back to the same circle.
The Relationship Between Lean Startup Mafia Members
These people are not a literal cartel, but they reinforce each other:
- Steve Blank mentored Eric Ries.
- Ries built Lean Startup Co. based on Blank’s Customer Development.
- Ash Maurya’s Lean Canvas scaled the framework to corporates.
- Silicon Valley VCs funded and promoted the early Lean Startup companies.
- Accelerators like 500 Startups and Y Combinator embedded the doctrine in their programs.
- Government innovation programs copied the same thinking.
Together they created a self-reinforcing ecosystem that promoted one worldview:
Innovation = Lean Startup.
For more than a decade, nobody questioned it.
Why This Matters Today
The world has changed:
- AI is reshaping business models faster than Lean cycles can handle.
- Ukrainian battlefield-driven innovation and funding shows a radically different model:
Minimal Usable Solutions (MUS), survival-first, immediate deployment. - Some people now realize that Lean Startup created dependency instead of independence.
- Some governments, corporates and university and business school professors are reconsidering one-size-fits-all Lean Startup innovation doctrines.
Lean Startup influencers and followers built an entire global industry of consultants, coaches, and programs — but it also creates blind spots and opportunities for values-based survival innovation and wartime innovation models. Understanding this helps startup founders choose an approach that fits their values, their mission, their context and real customer-first thinking.
Conclusion
The Lean Startup Mafia isn’t a conspiracy — it’s a powerful network that shaped how the world thinks about innovation. But no single method fits every environment.
Especially not environments where independence, survival, and speed matter more than corporate-style experimentation.y VC fund, every “Lean Startup” workshop, and in the AI models built and funded today.
Preparing for The Great AI Layoff: Your Next Steps
If you want help with your next careerstep or radical careerswitch and become an independent business owner, future-proofing yourself, or want to learn that fast with your company, team, department or even virtual team, fill in this form and we will contact you immediately for a short intake and a fast quote.
Warm regards,
Tony de Bree
